Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Kendall Butt Extra Credit Question 1: Characterization in Oleanna

With all of the questions posed in Oleanna, it helps to step back and focus on the tools used by the writer that serve as the base for the entire play. First impressions hold strong, as everyone knows, and the first impressions of of both Carol and John provide base for the remainder of the production. Carol is designed in a way to give the audience no choice but to absolutely disregard her authority. She is not only completely obnoxious in her line of question and actions, but her first outfit is quite loose and baggy which can instill a negative view on her character for the viewer. John, on the other hand, is first showcased in his highly prestigious office and clean attire. He is created as not only a educated man, but also a rational character, and this decreases the regard for Carol's intelligence. Carol's character also tends to create facial expressions that are most often scrutinized and confused. John, on the other hand is seen as clear faced and generally calm in his dealings with Carol. His relaxed demeanor and undying effort to use extremely verbose language leads to intensify Carol's panicked and paranoid  attitude and questioning. It can also be easily observed that John is comfortable in his environment. He strides around his office, sitting on desks and table, and does not hesitate on an opportunity to be at an angle above Carol. Opposite this, Carol timidly follows John's lead and only appears headstrong in her efforts  to interrupt and argue with John. Her flustered interjections give away her low self-confidence. Despite the basis of the characters created through their body language and appearance, the play can lead viewers to find a sense of empathy for Carol, and a loathing for John nearing the end--the fact being that the main determinant of one's feelings towards these characters is their own socio-economic standing.

2 comments:

  1. Kendall, I definitely agree with your first impression that Carol is designed in a way to give the audience no choice but to absolutely disregard her authority. I believe that she has absolutely taken John's actions and words out of context. I believe that John might have abused his power as professor, but in the first act he definitely didn't overstep any boundaries when it comes to sexual harassment. He was only acting as a empathetic teacher towards his student and Carol falsely accuses him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked your point about how John was always at an angle above Carol. I didn't even think of that. That certainly explains why he would repeatedly ask Carol to take a seat. Now I don't think he did this to display his power or anything like that, but rather because that is how it is supposed to be. At least, that's how high schools taught it: teacher's hold the power in classrooms and should be above the students (in front of the room or at a podium). College has this same power dynamic: Professor holds the power, students shut the hell up. So John was always seated above Carol simply because it is proper. He's the professor, and she really should have shut the hell up.
    And on your thoughts about physical appearances, John was always dressed nicely. There's no denying that. He looked good. But why did the writer/producer guy decide to display John with the beard? Now that may not be important at all, or could just be something as simple as William H. Macy not wanting to shave; but, you know, just a thought.

    ReplyDelete